These yummy and creepy Witch Fingers Rice Krispie Treats are made out of crunchy, marshmallow-y Rice Krispie Cereal. Cute! Fun! Easy!

Closeup on four Witch Finger Rice Krispie Treats sitting on a green surface.

Yummy and creepy Witch Fingers made out of crunchy, marshmallow-y Rice Krispie Cereal. Cute! Fun! Easy! This colorful and festive dessert is a great treat for a Halloween Party and you won’t believe how easy these Witch Fingers Rice Krispie Treats are to make!

How to Make the Rice Krispie Treat Mixture

Closeup on a white sauce pan filled with warm Rice Krispie Treat mixture.

The base for our Witch Fingers Rice Krispie Treats is our Best Ever Rice Krispie Treat Recipe which we have adjusted and perfected over the years until it is now absolutely the best Rice Krispie Treat recipe we have ever tasted.  You can all the directions you’ll need to make these delicious treats right here.

How to Color the Rice Krispie Treat Mixture

Closeup on a medium pan filled with green Rice Krispie Treat mixture with a green spatula.

Step 2: To tint the Rice Krispie Treat mixture, add the food coloring to the melted marshmallows and butter BEFORE you add the Rice Krispie Cereal.   To get this pretty Green Color we used 6 drops of Yellow Wilton Color Right Food Coloring and 3 drops of Blue.  

How to Make the Witch Fingers

Collage image showing how to mold the Rice Krispie Treat mixture into a Witch Finger.

Step 3:  We measured 7 oz. of Rice Krispie Treat mixture for each finger.  You can skip this step but it allowed us to create 10 Witch Fingers that were all pretty much the same size.
Step 4: Then we simply molded the green Rice Krispie Treat mixture into a finger shape – a cylinder that was a little bigger on the bottom than on the top.

How to Decorate the Witch Fingers

Collage image showing the steps for adding the Almond silver to the Witch Finger.

Step 5: The creepy Witch Fingernail is made with a sliced Almonds and some Red Icing.
Steps 6 & 7:  Using a blob of red icing, we attached an almond slice to the tip of the Witch Finger Rice Krispie Treat.

Closeup on 10 Witch Finger Rice Krispie Treats laying on a silver cookie sheet covered with parchment paper.

Step 8: Allow the icing to set up and you have 10 beautiful (?) Witch Finger Rice Krispie Treats.  Well, they might not be beautiful but they are delicious. We love how these Witch Finger Rice Krispie Treats turned out … what a cute and creepy treat for a Halloween Party.  Fun! Fun! Fun!

Closeup on six Witch Finger Rice Krispie Treats laying on a green surface covered with a spider web pattern.

Other Halloween Rice Krispie Treats You Will Love

Did you Make This Recipe? Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @twosisterscrafting on Instagram so we can see it!

And don’t forget to follow us on Pinterest, Facebook, and Instagram!

Witch Fingers Rice Krispie Treats

These yummy and creepy Witch Fingers Rice Krispie Treats are made out of crunchy, marshmallow-y Rice Krispie Cereal. Cute! Fun! Easy!

Ingredients

  • 3 cups Rice Krispie Cereal
  • 3 tablespoons Butter (Sweet Cream, Salted)
  • 3 cups Mini Marshmallows
  • 10 Sliced Almonds
  • Wilton Red Icing
  • Wilton Color Right Food Coloring System – Yellow
  • Wilton Color Right Food Coloring System – Blue

Instructions

  1. Make a 3 cup batch of our Best Ever Rice Krispie Treat Recipe.
  2. Add green food coloring to the melted marshmallow mixture BEFORE adding the Rice Krispie Cereal.
  3. Measured 7 oz. of Rice Krispie Treat mixture for each finger.
  4. Mold the green Rice Krispie Treat mixture into a finger shape - a cylinder that was a little bigger on the bottom than on the top.
  5. Attach the Almond slice finger nail to the top of the Witch finger with a blob of red icing.

Did you Make this Recipe? Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @twosisterscrafting on Instagram so we can see it!